This Here Defeat


The voice of David Bowie, the theatricality of Anthony Hegarty, that’s what we praise this music for.“ – Rolling Stone









Art Direction, Design – BUREAU Mario Lombardo*

Engineer – João Eleutério

Management – Christian Jerger

Mastered By – H. J. Maucksch*

Mixed By – Klaus Scheuermann

Music By, Lyrics By – Scott William Matthew*

Photography By [Photo Of Front Cover] – Ole Hein Pedersen

Photography By [Photo Showing An Artpiece] – Vilhelm Hammershøi

Producer – Jürgen Stark

Soul To Save
Ruined Heart
This Here Defeat
Here We Go Again
Palace Of Tears



Mit dem Laden des Videos akzeptieren Sie die Datenschutzerklärung von YouTube.
Mehr erfahren

Video laden

Klicken Sie auf den unteren Button, um den Inhalt von Spotify zu laden.

Inhalt laden


What does love sound like when it is not there? Singing about it is never easy because love is, in every respect, greater than any word ever meant to describe it – or any sound for that matter. A person who is happily in love has no real need for song, let alone a reason for writing one. Praising love, well, that is usually not very successful either. The songs that truly mean something are apparently those about its absence. They are about longing for love, it dying away and, ultimately, losing it. until nothing more is left of love but a memory. But it never completely goes away, just as the pain never completely disappears. What does remain, is: „A burning effigy of you and me, it’s something that we used to be.“

These two lines are how „This Here Defeat“ starts off, the 5th and forthcoming album of Scott Matthew, who can sing like no one else about how it is to long for love and feel it slip away (he has sung and still sings about other sides of life too, but not as intensely and poignantly as he does about love, and quite naturally so). More precisely, his new album begins with the sound of strings and an electric guitar. The former are no surprise to those familiar with Scott’s previous work. But, an electric guitar? I couldn’t remember hearing that in one of his songs before. This indeed marks a greater change for him: to include the sound of an electric guitar on “This Here Defeat” – at times ominous, then cutting and again appeasing, accompanied by a ponderous drum beat, the soft and clear, bell sound of a Fender Rhodes, … And if you listen very closely, you can even hear electronic sounds and effects on one of Scott’s records for the first time ever, although subtly interwoven.

Scott Matthew is a musician who has chosen early on to creatively limit the tonal aesthetics of his music in favour of the grandness found in minimalism, and not in the spectacular. Cello, piano, ukulele and acoustic guitar have always had their place in his songs right next to Scott’s voice, rarely more or anything else. His lyrics and voice, too, have always seemed to have found their distinct subject and unmistakable tonality: It is a lamentation. But not bitter, nor whining – and never hopeless. There is and always has been a feeling of warmth and an indelible longing; a protest against what some call fate; a certainty that, however lonely we may be in our individual existences, we all experience and go through the same solitude together „Come on the disaffected, believe what we need matters, I’ve had a premonition, a place where we can grieve“, Scott sings in one of the centrepieces of this new album, „Skyline“. And when all hope seems lost, we can still rely on the tongue-in-cheek knowledge of how absurd our actions, thoughts or feelings can be to kindle it anew. Hope may not always be the best friend one can have in life, but at least it is always there when it is needed most. And a sigh from Scott in its best expression is a shout of hope to kick off the fresh start we all make time after time: „Here we go again …

I’m very, very proud of the album”, Scott says, “and I think I’m most proud about it, because I didn’t think it would happen. Only a few months before we recorded it, I thought I would probably never make a new album. I had a time in my life, not too long ago, where I didn’t want to be the sad guy anymore. I just had my heart broken yet again, and was wondering: Do I really want to be the guy that will use music as a catalyst for the heartbreak he experienced in his life? I went on tour during this time, and literally lost my voice – I couldn’t sing anymore. When I look back at the time, it was like hell, and yet it was like divine intervention. As though something was coming down saying: Okay, you don’t want to do this anymore, so I’ll take it away from you. Only then did I understand, how much I love what I do.”

This was all only possible now though with a little earthly help flown to New York, the hometown of the Australian singer. Scott had been writing songs sporadically over the past two years and had already recorded demo versions. But he was not entirely satisfied with them – he was still looking for the right instrumentation and arrangements. So he asked his guitarist from Germany, Jürgen Stark, to visit him. He and Scott had been friends for years and had also played together on stage. They locked themselves in Scott’s apartment in Brooklyn for two weeks to work on the songs – some alone, some together. After that, it was clear, this album would be made and Jürgen Stark was going to be the producer: Scott has found in Jürgen a true musical collaborator. The album was then recorded within six days together with Scott’s longtime musical companions, Eugene Lemcio (piano, bass) and Sam Taylor (cello) in Lisbon, the city, that Scott has been in love with ever since he worked there together with Rodrigo Leão (co-founder of Madredeus).

„This album is a nice diversion of what I’ve done before“, Scott tells us, “without being something completely new. It’s more of an extension of what I’ve done before – but it’s different.” The first tracks may be darker and, at the same time, more solumn than Scott’s previous work, more unabated and elegiacal. Until the title track comes, almost as suddenly as a rainbow appearing in the sky – a classic pop song, soft with feather-light instrumentation, and lyrics that are sad and humourous at once: “This Here Defeat” is a song about someone who turns out after all is said and done to be quite a lousy ex-lover, to whom the narrator does not even feel like dedicating a song. A perfectly paradoxical song indeed, that, according to the lyrics, should not even exist. A goodbye and good riddance from the songwriter. Not at all a defeat, as the title seemingly admits, but a triumph of the betrayed and estranged.

Before it ends with “Palace Of Tears”, this new album from Scott Matthew pays hommage to the life of his recently deceased grandfather in a touching song. Scott was unable to attend his funeral, so he wrote “Ode”, a last farewell to a revered, beloved person. Only in the very last line of the lyrics does it become evident that this song is written about Scott’s grandfather – those who listen to the song may think of someone who was, perhaps, just as special to them. “Ode” was played at the funeral ceremony for Scott’s grandfather; because songs, unlike people, can always be there, at any time and everyhwere. “Songs”, Scott explains, “are a representation of a moment. But it’s not THE moment, just a moment. Then it comes to the listener and the song becomes THE moment. That was my motivation to write songs in the first place. I was like: I want to give back what people gave me, so that they would be able to have their own stories within a song. When I was a teenager, my motivation was always to make albums that said: This is not for me, this is for somebody else. It may be validating my experiences, but it is not mine anymore once it’s recorded and released. It’s not mine, it’s theirs.”


Gepostet am

14. August 2023